by 
Introduction
Greetings, readers! Welcome to our comprehensive guide on choice of law attorney-client privilege. In this article, we will dive deep into the intricacies of this complex legal principle that protects the confidentiality of communications between attorneys and their clients. We’ll explore various aspects of choice of law, including its application in different jurisdictions, the exceptions to the privilege, and its implications in legal proceedings.
What is Choice of Law Attorney-Client Privilege?
Simply put, choice of law attorney-client privilege allows clients to communicate with their attorneys openly and honestly, knowing that their communications will remain confidential. This privilege is essential for the attorney-client relationship to thrive, as it allows clients to seek legal advice and assistance without fear of their conversations being disclosed to third parties.
Jurisdictional Application of Choice of Law Attorney-Client Privilege
United States
In the United States, the attorney-client privilege is governed by both federal and state laws. The federal common law recognizes the privilege, and it has been codified in several federal statutes, including the Federal Rules of Evidence and the attorney-client privilege under the Ethics in Government Act. Additionally, each state has its own laws governing the attorney-client privilege, which may vary slightly from the federal rules.
International Jurisdictions
The attorney-client privilege also exists in international jurisdictions, although its scope may vary depending on the specific legal system. In some civil law countries, such as France and Germany, the attorney-client privilege is more limited than in the United States, and it may not extend to all types of communications between attorneys and their clients.
Exceptions to Choice of Law Attorney-Client Privilege
Crime-Fraud Exception
One of the exceptions to the attorney-client privilege is the crime-fraud exception. This exception allows for the disclosure of privileged communications if the client used the attorney’s services to commit a crime or fraud. For example, if a client confessed to murder to their attorney, the attorney could be compelled to disclose that communication to law enforcement.
Client Waiver
Another exception to the attorney-client privilege is client waiver. If a client voluntarily discloses a privileged communication to a third party, the privilege is waived for that specific communication. For example, if a client discusses a privileged conversation with their spouse, the privilege would be waived for that conversation.
Choice of Law Attorney-Client Privilege in Legal Proceedings
Discovery
In legal proceedings, the attorney-client privilege can be asserted to prevent the disclosure of privileged communications during discovery. However, there are certain circumstances in which the privilege may be overcome, such as when the crime-fraud exception applies or when the client has waived the privilege.
Trial
At trial, the attorney-client privilege can be asserted to prevent the introduction of privileged communications as evidence. However, the privilege may be overcome if the witness has waived the privilege or if the crime-fraud exception applies.
Table: Summary of Choice of Law Attorney-Client Privilege
| Jurisdiction | Privilege Scope | Exceptions |
|---|---|---|
| United States | Broad | Crime-fraud exception, client waiver |
| France | Limited | May not extend to all communications |
| Germany | More limited than France | May not include pre-litigation communications |
Conclusion
The choice of law attorney-client privilege is a complex but essential legal principle that protects the confidentiality of communications between attorneys and their clients. Stay tuned for more in-depth articles on our website, where we explore other fascinating legal topics that can help you navigate the complexities of the legal system.
FAQ About Choice of Law Attorney Client Privilege
What is choice of law attorney client privilege?
- Choice of law attorney-client privilege refers to the ability of attorneys and clients to choose the law of a particular jurisdiction to govern their communications, even if those communications take place in a different jurisdiction.
What are the benefits of choice of law attorney client privilege?
- It allows attorneys and clients to select the jurisdiction with the most favorable laws governing attorney-client privilege. This can provide greater protection for confidential communications.
What are the limitations of choice of law attorney client privilege?
- Choice of law attorney-client privilege is not absolute. Courts may refuse to apply the chosen law if it would violate public policy or if the law of the forum jurisdiction is more favorable to the client.
How do I choose the governing law for my attorney-client communications?
- You and your attorney can agree on the governing law in writing. This can be done through a retainer agreement or a separate agreement.
What happens if I do not choose a governing law?
- If you do not choose a governing law, the law of the jurisdiction where the communication takes place will likely apply.
Can I change the governing law after the fact?
- It is generally possible to change the governing law after the fact, but it may be difficult to do so. The new law must be chosen in good faith and must not violate public policy.
What are the risks of choosing a foreign law to govern attorney-client communications?
- Choosing a foreign law may make it more difficult to enforce the privilege in court. It may also increase the costs of litigation.
How can I protect my attorney-client communications from disclosure?
- In addition to choosing a governing law, there are other steps you can take to protect your communications, such as using encryption, limiting the number of people who have access to your communications, and destroying confidential documents.
What should I do if I am subpoenaed to testify about attorney-client communications?
- If you are subpoenaed to testify about attorney-client communications, you should immediately contact your attorney. Your attorney can help you assert your privilege and protect your confidential communications.
What are the penalties for violating attorney-client privilege?
- Violating attorney-client privilege can result in a variety of penalties, including fines, imprisonment, and disbarment.
