by 
Introduction
Greetings, readers! Vexatious complaints are a serious issue facing attorneys in North Carolina. These complaints can waste time and resources, clog the courts, and harass innocent parties. In this article, we will explore the legal landscape of vexatious complaints in North Carolina, providing you with the information you need to protect yourself and your clients.
What is a Vexatious Complaint?
A vexatious complaint is a legal pleading that is filed without a legitimate basis and is intended to harass or annoy the defendant. These complaints often contain frivolous claims, lack any legal merit, and are repeatedly filed by the same individual or group of individuals.
Filing a Vexatious Complaint
In North Carolina, several statutes address the filing of vexatious complaints. N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-261 provides that courts may strike pleadings that are "scandalous, immaterial, or impertinent" or that "tend to delay the fair administration of justice." N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1A-1, Rule 11(b) further prohibits attorneys from filing papers that are "frivolous" or "intended to cause delay."
Consequences of Filing a Vexatious Complaint
Individuals who file vexatious complaints may face several consequences, including:
- Sanctions by the court, such as fines or imprisonment
- Disbarment or suspension from the practice of law for attorneys
- Reimbursement of the defendant’s attorney fees and costs
Defending Against a Vexatious Complaint
If you are facing a vexatious complaint, there are several steps you can take to defend yourself:
Motion to Strike
The first step is to file a motion to strike the complaint. This motion should argue that the complaint is frivolous, lacks legal merit, and is intended to harass or annoy you.
Motion for Sanctions
If the court strikes the complaint, you may also file a motion for sanctions. This motion requests that the court impose sanctions on the individual who filed the vexatious complaint.
Request for Protective Order
In some cases, you may need to request a protective order to prevent the individual from continuing to file vexatious complaints against you.
Table: Common Vexatious Complaint Provisions
| Provision | Description |
|---|---|
| N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1-261 | Courts may strike pleadings that are "scandalous, immaterial, or impertinent" or that "tend to delay the fair administration of justice." |
| N.C. Gen. Stat. § 1A-1, Rule 11(b) | Attorneys are prohibited from filing papers that are "frivolous" or "intended to cause delay." |
| N.C. Gen. Stat. § 51-71 | Provides for a $10,000 fine and/or imprisonment for up to six months for filing a frivolous or vexatious lawsuit. |
| N.C. Gen. Stat. § 7A-148 | Allows the court to strike frivolous or vexatious pleadings and award attorney fees and costs to the defendant. |
Conclusion
Vexatious complaints are a serious issue that can harm both attorneys and defendants. By understanding the legal landscape and following the steps outlined in this article, you can protect yourself and your clients from these frivolous and harassing lawsuits.
Check out our other articles for more information on legal topics affecting attorneys in North Carolina.
FAQ about Attorney Vexatious Complaint NC Case Law
What is a vexatious complaint?
A vexatious complaint is a lawsuit that is frivolous, repetitive, or intended to harass or annoy the defendant.
What are the elements of a vexatious complaint claim?
The elements of a vexatious complaint claim are:
- The complaint is frivolous, repetitive, or intended to harass or annoy the defendant.
- The complaint has caused the defendant actual damages.
- The defendant has a meritorious defense to the complaint.
What are the penalties for filing a vexatious complaint?
The penalties for filing a vexatious complaint include:
- Dismissal of the complaint
- Award of attorney fees and costs to the defendant
- Sanctions from the court
What is the case law on attorney vexatious complaint in North Carolina?
The North Carolina Court of Appeals has held that a complaint is vexatious if it is "frivolous, repetitive, or intended to harass or annoy the defendant." In Sears, Roebuck & Co. v. Stimpson, 129 N.C. App. 167 (1998), the court found that a complaint was vexatious where the plaintiff had filed multiple lawsuits against the defendant based on the same set of facts.
What are some examples of vexatious complaints?
Some examples of vexatious complaints include:
- Lawsuits that are filed without any legal basis
- Lawsuits that are filed repeatedly against the same defendant
- Lawsuits that are filed for the sole purpose of harassing or annoying the defendant
What should I do if I am served with a vexatious complaint?
If you are served with a vexatious complaint, you should file a motion to dismiss the complaint. You should also consider filing a motion for sanctions against the plaintiff.
What are the defenses to a vexatious complaint claim?
The defenses to a vexatious complaint claim include:
- The complaint is not frivolous, repetitive, or intended to harass or annoy the defendant.
- The complaint has not caused the defendant actual damages.
- The defendant does not have a meritorious defense to the complaint.
How can I prevent being sued for filing a vexatious complaint?
The best way to prevent being sued for filing a vexatious complaint is to consult with an attorney before filing a lawsuit. An attorney can help you determine whether your lawsuit is frivolous, repetitive, or intended to harass or annoy the defendant.
What are the consequences of being found liable for filing a vexatious complaint?
The consequences of being found liable for filing a vexatious complaint can include:
- Dismissal of the complaint
- Award of attorney fees and costs to the defendant
- Sanctions from the court
Where can I find more information about attorney vexatious complaint NC case law?
You can find more information about attorney vexatious complaint NC case law by visiting the North Carolina Courts website.
